The failure of Clarity to advance in the Senate has shifted the center of gravity for crypto regulation in the US to the SEC and CFTC: the agencies are already trying to expand legal trading of digital assets and access for institutional players, but without Congress, key gaps in oversight remain unresolved.
The Digital Asset Market Clarity Act has not moved forward in the Senate. Now, the next stage of rulemaking for the crypto industry effectively depends on the US Securities and Exchange Commission and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission. This opens the door to new on-chain tools, tokenization, and institutional trading, but at the same time raises the question: how sustainable can regulatory certainty be if it is created by agencies rather than lawmakers?
Company executives and lawyers generally agree on one thing: regulation of digital assets will continue to develop. Disagreements begin when it comes to the reliability of such a process. Some believe the actions of the SEC and CFTC provide a sufficient basis for launching new products, while others warn that rules created by agencies are easier to revise under political or judicial pressure.
Lev Breido, associate professor of law at William & Mary Law School, believes that the Clarity story has revealed internal contradictions in the crypto industry. Disputes arose over a variety of issues: from ethical standards to the fight for profitability, which involves local banks.
The coalition, which seemed united in opposing Gensler, realized that definitions create winners and losers.
SEC and CFTC Fill Gaps Without a New Law
Despite the legislative pause, regulators have already begun to act. On September 17, the SEC introduced a five-year “Innovation Exemption.” It allows qualified platforms to trade tokenized US equities through a blockchain liquidity pool while the agency prepares permanent rules.
On October 5, the CFTC requested comments on rules for margin retail trading of cryptocurrencies and on a new registration category for crypto markets. This does not mean an immediate launch of a ready-made regime: it is a long process of public discussion and subsequent rulemaking.
Another important area concerns asset custody. The SEC proposal from October 1 will allow state-level trust companies to provide custody of clients’ crypto assets. Investment advisers and funds will also be able to self-custody such assets if they meet established conditions.
Looking ahead to 2027, Breido expects the SEC to focus on finalizing rules for the placement and custody of digital assets, as well as continuing to develop the exemption for tokenized equities. In his view, the joint interpretive release by the SEC and CFTC, published in March, has become an important pillar: it replaces previous guidance and gives agencies the opportunity to coordinate their approach within the current legal framework.
The main unresolved problem remains. Regular spot trading without leverage still lacks a full federal regime, except for the CFTC’s authority to combat fraud and manipulation. This is the gap Clarity was supposed to close.
Why Business Sees Opportunity in the Pause
For some market participants, the absence of a law does not seem to be only an obstacle. On the contrary, some executives believe that working through regulatory agencies can deliver commercial results faster than a lengthy legislative process.
The SEC and CFTC are already taking active steps to give markets the regulatory certainty they need. This could trigger a wave of M&A deals in digital assets, traditional financial services, and fintech.
This is how Paul McCaffery, head of digital assets at investment bank KBW, assessed the situation.
Bitwise Chief Investment Officer Matt Hougan also considers the agency route more favorable in the short term. In his opinion, passing a law would still require several years of subsequent rulemaking. He also expects more protocols to begin using token buybacks, especially “buy and burn” models, as SEC clarifications, in his words, increase investor confidence.
For developers, the most important question is different: will the regulator separate software creation from the activities of a financial intermediary? Kathy Yoon, chief legal officer of Temporal, a research and development company in the Solana ecosystem, expressed hope that the SEC will recognize developers as software creators and not automatically treat their work as securities activity.
The fact that SEC staff are willing to speak directly on these topics can already be considered a victory.
At the same time, Yoon emphasized that responses from agency staff to frequently asked questions are not official SEC rules.
Michael Lai, global head of digital assets at market maker Flow Traders, believes comprehensive regulation is inevitable as financial markets move to 24/7 trading. He is closely watching innovation exemptions and possible rule changes for transfer agents, while European and Asian regimes are already moving forward.
The Main Risk Is Not the Idea of Rules but Their Implementation
Lawyers expect gradual progress but consider the most difficult stage to be the practical application of new approaches. Derek Lowery, head of legal at Newton Labs, formerly known as Magic Labs, calls implementation the main gap in the current system.
The biggest gap is implementation.
According to Lowery, without legislation, oversight of trading platforms, intermediaries, DeFi, and spot markets remains more complicated. At the same time, existing anti-money laundering, sanctions compliance, and recordkeeping requirements give compliance teams a foundation to build on.
Kevin Crozier, chief legal adviser at D3, a company working on domain name tokenization, believes that tokenized real-world assets especially need clearer jurisdictional boundaries.
Agency actions are important and useful, but they do not provide the long-term certainty that a law can offer.
Jim Petrila, chief legal officer at Dromos Labs, developer of Aerodrome and Velodrome, is more optimistic. He believes that increased liquidity and the spread of tokenized securities on public blockchains could make a reversal virtually impossible within two years.
For DeFi, this is a bullish signal.
However, the benefits of the new stage of regulation may be distributed unevenly. Hougan believes that Clarity’s failure maintains a regulatory barrier that benefits Coinbase, Kraken, and other major incumbents. Such a situation may delay the emergence of competitors capable of reducing costs.
As a result, the market gets a paradoxical picture: experiments may move faster, but the question of who will actually be able to compete and how robust the new rules will be remains open. According to Breido, only Congress can create a comprehensive framework with the durability of a full-fledged law.
